Children come into the world programmed to learn, to learn fast, and particularly to learn by copying what they see around them.
Many a hapless parent has been caught out by a small child’s tendency to brightly repeat in public places words and phrases that were not intended to be overheard.
Imitation learning is so central to child development that it’s relevant to pretty much every aspect of childrearing.
Want your children to eat healthily? Replace cupcakes with apples and pears in your own diet.
What your children to have great body image? Say things to yourself in front of the mirror like “isn’t the human body fantastic? How lucky I am to have this one! Look how incredible it is”
Want to encourage your children to be confident around (say) dogs, or spiders, or when dealing with wasps? Ruthlessly crush any fear you might be feeling and pretend nonchalance in front of them.
Teaching by living your ideal is often great for you, too. I know my diet’s improved dramatically in the three and a half years since my first son was born.
So what does this have to do with respect?
Well, I want my children to learn to respect others, and to respect themselves. I’ve been realising that the most powerful tool in my parenting arsenal in this case is going to be how I show respect to them.
Respecting children looks a bit different from respecting adults. I would not seize an adult I respected, throw them onto a changing mat, and strip off their underwear regardless of their protests.
Babies are not equipped for bodily autonomy. They have needs that can only be met by manhandling them. They also don’t have enough grasp of human communicated to understand explanations.
However, it’s possible to start respecting personal space at a very young age. Here are some things I’ve been trying:
- Ask “can we have a cuddle?” and accept the answer “no”, even if that’s just delivered as a squawk of protest. The question doesn’t have to be verbal – you can hold out your arms invitingly and watch for the response. With a baby too small to communicate, you can still watch how they react to your cuddles and follow their cues on what they want as far as possible. As they get older they might enjoy chase-and-cuddle games, but it shouldn’t be past the wit of an adult to detect when the game goes from being fun to being frustrating for them.
- Give warning when I’m going to override a baby’s physical autonomy to do something to or with their body. “I’m going to put you on the mat and change your nappy”, perhaps. Or “you’re going in the buggy”.
- Always tickle gently, allowing plenty of breaks so that the baby can catch their breath from the laughter and show you their underlying emotion. Tickling can make a child laugh even when they hate it. If they seem unhappy after the laugh, or say “no!” stop at once. You can always start again a minute or so later if it seems like they want that after all.
- Count to three, out loud, before picking up a child that needs to come with you. This one kind of started by accident as an echo of the “I’m going to count to three and then there will be a consequence if you haven’t done X”. It’s turned out to be extremely useful, though. It’s not an either-you-do-this-or-I-do-that routine, it’s just a way of giving warning before I swoop in to pick them up. Since they’re less startled, and feel less rushed, they are also less likely to cry and protest when they are then picked up.
- Discuss plans that are going to affect the child, with the child. This is more relevant for older toddlers, but even with a little baby I’ve always tried to run through, in the morning, the things that are going to happen that day. It doesn’t have to be detailed – a classic version is “Daddy’s taking you to nursery and will pick you up, but Mummy will get home from work in time to put you to bed.” Or, “we’re going to play in our house this morning, boys, and then we’ll go to Grandma’s house for lunch.”
- When you can, let a child make meaningful choices about what they do with their bodies and their time. Hold up three t-shirts and let them pick which one to wear. As if they want to go to the park or to the library. Have two or three cereals on option so they can decide what to eat for breakfast. It’s easiest if you make sure that you offer only options that are ok with you, so that you’ll be happy with whatever they plump for.
- Give warning when an activity is about to end. The magic words are “it’s time for one last thing” before we go home / have dinner / go to bed. Giving five minutes’ warning makes your control of their lives feel less arbitrary to them, and giving them a choice for the final activity helps them assert a little bit of control within the bigger picture of doing what you’ve decided should be done.
Close observation and restraint is the key, remembering that babies and toddlers are full people even if they’re still developing personalities.
How about times when you have to do things your way?
It’s obviously not always possible to respect a child’s wishes about what they do with their body. A three year old might want to get dressed by themselves, but if you’ve got to rush out of the door to get to nursery and on to work on time for an important meeting, you might have to say no.
When overriding a child’s wishes, I try to ensure two things:
- Consistency. I want my boys to know what to expect from me. I set general rules where I can: we don’t go near a road without me holding your hand. If I need you and you’re not coming, I’ll count to three before picking you up. Stinky nappies get changed as soon as possible, even if you’d rather keep playing.
- Explanation. I tell my boys why I am doing something they don’t want. If I don’t change this nappy soon, you might get an ouchy red rash. We need to go now because otherwise we’ll be late for nursery, and Mummy will be late to work. You can’t wear that top today because it’s got avocado on it and it needs to go in the wash.
This approach is one I’ve been feeling my way towards since my oldest son was born late in 2014. Some elements have been in place almost since then, and others have evolved over time. It’s only recently that I’ve started to realise the underlying principle I’ve been working towards.
I want my sons to know at a bone-deep level that they matter and that other people matter. I want them to have an instinct to check that the other person also wants to cuddle.
In short, my goal is to respect my children, so that they learn to respect themselves and to respect others.
Obligatory Aretha Franklin: